Has anyone gone from 4V to 5V

[griffmac12]

I bought a 4V 6MT in Dec 2024. Only cars I considered were the two BWs. I ultimately went with the 4V because I thought it would be more fun for my usage. My commute is 4miles each way, on surface and neighborhood streets. I don't track the car but I do a fair amount of country/canyon driving on the weekends. I rarely take road trips in this car and rarely use backseat. It was hard to even test drive manual versions of the car and I only drive the 5BW MT once. For a while, I was leaning toward 5BW for the V8 and because I felt like the car wouldn't depreciate. Ultimately, chose 4V because I thought it would be more fun to drive and it hasn't disappointed.

My son is looking for a used 4V (low mileage 2022 is in his price range) but he has been pushing, just let me take yours and you need to get a 5V. I still have this itch to have the 5V from before. I know, as far as cars go, that it will be a good "investment". I'm worried my daily driving will be more cruising at 1800 rpm than working the gears without going 100mph I can do in the 4V. Worried about the 5V gearing because I love this transmission and want to use it.

Has anyone switched? Thoughts on how it went for you

 

[JLayer]

I switched. No regrets here.

At the time the price was out of reach for me on the 5 so I went with the 4. It was a fun car to drive for the 2 years I owned it. However the 5 was always in my mind and made the decision to trade. Like I said no regrets.

 

[jbawden]

Seems to be a popular move based on numerous data points I've experienced. The 5BW will commute just like your 4BW. The LT4 has loads of torque and doesn't need RPM for city driving making it even better suited to your use case. I think there is a bit of a misconception on how versatile the LT4 paired to a manual is. The entire premise of the 5BW is that it's content going to Target as it is cutting 0-60 hot laps and going 90mph in 2nd at your favorite road course.

 

[nordique14]

My son is looking for a used 4V (low mileage 2022 is in his price range) but he has been pushing, just let me take yours and you need to get a 5V. I still have this itch to have the 5V from before.

Your son should go into sales. It seems to me your only real choice is what options you get on the 5BW.

 

[griffmac12]

Your son should go into sales. It seems to me your only real choice is what options you get on the 5BW.

I'm headed to a conference next week and I should be able to drive a 5V 6MT while I am there. It's doesn't have PP - which I would like to try and feel like I would want. As a PP owner, what's your take on it.

 

[1Evil55]

I doubt you'd regret it. If it turns out the 5 isn't for you, I'm sure the kid could convince you to trade back to the 4. I doubt he'd complain about moving into the 5.

 

[Champale]

I currently own both with manuals. The 5 is better in many ways and I find it more fun to drive than the 4, even just tooling around town. It has a dangerous edge to it, too, which is fun if you are a lunatic and turn everything off. But the 4 is also a wonderful car. If I had to choose, it would be the 5BW with zero hesitation.

 

[nordique14]

Here is a good thread about the PP ride quality.

CT5-V Thread 'Precision Pack Ride Quality Analysis'

Dec 28, 2025

@jvp was kind enough to bring his new 5BW with the precision package over yesterday. We thought it would be fun to do a back to back test drive of his car and my 22 with the standard suspension. Same day, same route, both on the PS4 tires. This video breaks down my impressions and does a bit of a data dive specific to ride quality.

• poor-sha
• Replies: 17
• Forum: Blackwing General Discussion

• 
• 

My recommendation is to get it if 1) you do track and back road driving or 2) if you were planning on getting the CCB, at which point it is only an additional $9k. It is a very expensive package to get if you are fine with the iron rotors and is subtle enough that will only get the benefit at the handling limit.

 

[griffmac12]

I would not spec CCs standalone. I definitely prefer feeling those imperfections a little. I have this fear I am going to lose a bit of the - for lack of a better word - precision there is with the 4. That's why I have assumed I would want a PP car. Gonna be keeping my eye out for a PP car I can drive somewhere near me.

 

[Le Monstre]

Not sure how old your son is, but I would trade the 4BW for the 5BW to get the most return possible, and then find him a non-molested ATS-V coupe to hoon in. Win win and everyone is happy

 

[griffmac12]

Not sure how old your son is, but I would trade the 4BW for the 5BW to get the most return possible, and then find him a non-molested ATS-V coupe to hoon in. Win win and everyone is happy

Well, I am wanting to get him a slightly newer car for college since he will be doing 250mile road trips home. He has a 2018 Golf R 6MT that we paid $31K for 2.5 years ago, it's worth $30,700 now per KBB. I told him since he got a significant scholarship, we could trade that and get something around $50K. Since he wants a manual performance car, the options are pretty limited - Used 4VBW, F80 M3 or a closer to new Golf R. I liked idea of Integra Type S for reliability/easy maintenance but he ruled out due to FWD. He would definitely be winning if I just passed down my 2024 4V BW

 

[RDATLTE]

Well, I am wanting to get him a slightly newer car for college since he will be doing 250mile road trips home. He has a 2018 Golf R 6MT that we paid $31K for 2.5 years ago, it's worth $30,700 now per KBB. I told him since he got a significant scholarship, we could trade that and get something around $50K. Since he wants a manual performance car, the options are pretty limited - Used 4VBW, F80 M3 or a closer to new Golf R. I liked idea of Integra Type S for reliability/easy maintenance but he ruled out due to FWD. He would definitely be winning if I just passed down my 2024 4V BW

He sounds like a good kid. Give him the 4, sell the Golf and use that $ for a down payment on a 5.